Transparently Insecure Operational Technology: A Contextual Analysis
In cybersecurity, countering threats depends on an ability to see and respond to attacks. However, in operational technology, transparency is a double-edged sword. Some of the same connectivity developed to dynamically manage cyber physical systems also exposes vulnerabilities to attackers.
This paper will explore the impact of the increased connectivity of embedded devices with information technology environments and consequential gaps in analytic models and risk management methodologies. Of special concern, the rapid turn-around between OT scanning-to-exploitation is growing in scope and scale. In a rapidly changing environment, cyber defenders need to adapt threat hunting approaches to evolving threats through innovative approaches.
This research also evaluates how cyber defenders can assess threats particular to operational technology and develop situational awareness to better defend their networks. Cyber physical security ultimately depends on a deep understanding of the technologies at play, ability to analyze emerging threats, and holistic risk management. Technology-centered models will best enable asset owners, operators, and stakeholders to deter strategic surprise.
sans-transparently-insecure-operational-technology-a-contextual-analysis (PDF, 4.18MB)
6 Jan 2022Related Content
Code Modularity as a Heuristic for Malware Design
Research PaperMalware targeting industrial control systems (ICS) and critical infrastructure often exhibits a modular architecture, using a central loader to execute interchangeable payload modules.
- 7 Nov 2025
Webs of Deception: Using the SANS ICS Kill Chain to Flip the Advantage to the Defender
Research PaperDefending a small Industrial Control System (ICS) against sophisticated threats can seem futile. The...
- 14 Apr 2025
Industrial Control System Internal Network Security Monitoring with Open-Source Tools
Research PaperSecurity vendors have made many advances in internal network security monitoring (INSM) in recent...
- 5 Dec 2024
False Data Injection Attacks Against Distribution Automation Systems
Research PaperUtility companies increasingly rely on automated switching to provide their customers with a...
- 5 Dec 2024
Shedding Light on OT Anomalies: Parsing Proprietary OT Protocols with Zeek
Research PaperMany traditional intrusion detection systems (IDS) may struggle with the unique devices and...
- 9 Oct 2024
SANS 2024 State of ICS/OT Cybersecurity
Research PaperThis white paper, SANS Certified Instructor Jason Christopher explores the growing trends in cyber...
- 9 Oct 2024
- SANS Institute
Mode Matters: Monitoring PLCs for Detecting Potential ICS/OT Incidents
Research PaperThere is a blind spot regarding cyber security in many Industrial Control Systems (ICS)and...
- 28 Feb 2024
Can Open-Source Tools Be Used to Safely Scan a Modern ICS Environment?
Research PaperThis research delves into the long-standing belief within the Operational Technology (OT) security...
- 27 Nov 2023
Private 5G, "Not as Private as You May Think"
Research PaperPrivate 5G networks and the transition to Industry 4.0 are gaining traction as demand increases for...
- 10 Oct 2023
Implementing Scalable Security for Devices Without 802.1x Support
Research PaperEnterprises often implement 802.1x to control access to wired and wireless networks by...
- 21 Dec 2022
You Cannot Defend What You Cannot See: Gaining Insight into Proprietary Protocols through Custom Parsers with Zeek
Research PaperA vital component of any information security architecture is a network intrusion detection...
- 6 Jan 2022
Collection and Analysis of Serial-Based Traffic in Critical Infrastructure Control Systems
Research PaperThere is a blind spot the size of a 27-ton, 2.25-megawatt maritime diesel generator in the world's...
- 11 Feb 2021
Industrial Traffic Collection: Understanding the implications of Deploying visibility without impacting production
Research PaperDue to the critical nature of industrial environments and the lifetime of deployed assets, many...
- 21 Sep 2020
Fashion Industry (Securely) 4.0ward
Research PaperThe fashion market segment is going through a significant technological upgrade. The need to meet...
- 9 Sep 2020
60870-5-104 protocol snort rule customization
Research PaperOT Security emerges as a necessity due to its flat network implementation and criticality of systems...
- 10 Aug 2020
Vulnerabilities on the Wire: Mitigations for Insecure ICS Device Communication
Research PaperModbus TCP and other legacy ICS protocols ported over from serial communications are still widely...
- 12 Feb 2020
- Michael Hoffman
Guarding the Modern Castle: Providing Visibility into the BACnet Protocol
Research PaperBuilding automation devices are used to monitor and control HVAC, security, fire, lighting, and...
- 30 Oct 2019
Gaining Endpoint Log Visibility in ICS Environments
Research PaperThis paper examines WEF in the context of Windows ICS environments to determine if WEF is better suited for ICS environments than WMI pulling regarding bandwidth, security, and deployment considerations
- 11 Mar 2019
- Michael Hoffman
Who's in the Zone? A Qualitative Proof-of-Concept for Improving Remote Access Least-Privilege in ICS-SCADA Environments
Research PaperRemote access control in many ICS-SCADA environments is of limited effectiveness leading to...
- 4 Dec 2017
Man-In-The-Middle Attack Against Modbus TCP Illustrated with Wireshark
Research PaperThough attacks on the industrial control system (ICS) and their protocols are not a new occurrence,...
- 20 Oct 2017
